Download PDF Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith
Reviewing, once again, will provide you something brand-new. Something that you have no idea after that exposed to be well understood with the book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith message. Some expertise or driving lesson that re obtained from reviewing publications is uncountable. Much more books Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith you review, more knowledge you obtain, and more possibilities to consistently enjoy checking out publications. Due to this factor, reading publication should be started from earlier. It is as what you could acquire from guide Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith
Download PDF Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith
Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith. One day, you will certainly discover a brand-new experience and understanding by spending even more money. Yet when? Do you believe that you need to get those all demands when having significantly money? Why do not you attempt to obtain something easy in the beginning? That's something that will lead you to know more about the world, experience, some locations, history, amusement, as well as a lot more? It is your own time to continue checking out routine. Among the e-books you could delight in now is Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith here.
The perks to take for reading the books Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith are pertaining to boost your life top quality. The life high quality will not just concerning the amount of understanding you will certainly acquire. Even you review the enjoyable or entertaining e-books, it will assist you to have enhancing life top quality. Feeling enjoyable will lead you to do something perfectly. In addition, the book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith will certainly offer you the lesson to take as a good factor to do something. You could not be useless when reading this book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith
Don't bother if you don't have adequate time to head to the book store as well as search for the preferred book to check out. Nowadays, the on-line book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith is concerning offer simplicity of checking out practice. You may not should go outside to search the publication Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith Searching as well as downloading the e-book qualify Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith in this short article will certainly provide you much better remedy. Yeah, on the internet publication Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith is a type of electronic publication that you could enter the web link download provided.
Why need to be this on the internet e-book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith You might not should go someplace to read the books. You can read this publication Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith every time as well as every where you want. Also it remains in our extra time or sensation tired of the jobs in the office, this corrects for you. Obtain this Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith today and also be the quickest person that completes reading this book Defending Life: A Moral And Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, By Francis J. Beckwith
Defending Life is the most comprehensive defense of the prolife position on abortion ever published. It is sophisticated, but still accessible to the ordinary citizen. Without high-pitched rhetoric or appeals to religion, the author offers a careful and respectful case for why the prolife view of human life is correct. He responds to the strongest prochoice arguments found in law, science, philosophy, politics, and the media. He explains and critiques Roe v. Wade, and he explains why virtually all the popular prochoice arguments fail. There is simply nothing like this book.
- Sales Rank: #298512 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Cambridge University Press
- Published on: 2007-08-13
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.98" h x .67" w x 5.98" l, .98 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 314 pages
Features
- Used Book in Good Condition
Review
"By a masterful marshalling of the pertinent arguments and a civil engagement with the counter-arguments, Beckwith makes a convincing case for law and social policy based on reason and natural rights rather than the will to power."
Reverend Richard John Neuhaus, Editor-in-Chief, First Things
"Like a superhero fighting on hostile turf with one arm tied behind his back, Francis J. Beckwith confronts every argument �- popular, legal, and philosophical �- that comes out against the pro-life position and fends them off one by one with steadfast rationality and exuberant invention. Between punches, drawing on the science of embryology and on philosophical anthropology, he develops a gracious and luminous case for the simple goodness of human life and the basic equality of all members of the human community from the moment of conception. Readers will judge for themselves whether or not he delivers a knock-out, but after working through Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case against Abortion Choice, no one can honestly hide behind such conceits as that all educated people support abortion, that nothing but blind faith rejects abortion rights, or that we are faced with a tragic choice between intelligence and life."
James R. Stoner, Jr., Louisiana State University
"Using an argument rooted in nondiscrimination and equality of persons, Beckwith deftly combines the analytical tools of philosophy, jurisprudence, and science to construct a brilliant case for governmental protection of the unborn. Critics will have difficulty refuting the logical conclusion that emerges from his basic premises."
Carol Swain, Vanderbilt University
"Francis Beckwith's Defending Life directly confronts, with careful analysis of specific texts, a wide variety of arguments made by prominent scholars who favor abortion rights, including Judith Thomson, David Boonin, Dean Stretton, Eileen McDonagh, Paul Simmons, and Stuart Rosenbaum. Those who read the book may not agree with Beckwith, but they will have no ground to complain that he has not taken the arguments on the other side seriously, since the book is a sustained analysis and critique of the most important arguments in defense of abortion rights. It is often said that the anti-abortion position is fundamentally religious. Defending Life, however, provides a comprehensive and sophisticated philosophical defense of the position - too often given short shrift in academia - that abortion involves the deliberate, unjustifiable killing of a member of the human community. It is an invaluable contribution to debate on this central social and political issue."
Christopher Wolfe, Marquette University
"As the Supreme Court's recent decision upholding the ban on partial birth abortion and the controversy over stem cell research make clear, the issues surrounding respect for life will continue at the forefront of American politics in the twenty-first century. Professor Beckwith's new book makes an important contribution to these debates. Defending Life is, and is likely to remain for a long time, the most thorough and detailed statement of the pro-life position. It is well-written and learned; the author's command of the relevant literatures, both legal and philosophic, is impressive."
Jean M. Yarbrough, Bowdoin College
"...in his new book, Defending Life, leading pro-life scholar Francis J. Beckwith offers a precise statement of the philosophical and jurisprudential case the movement has developed....the Supreme Court has not settled the abortion issue; and when the abortion question eventually returns to the electorate, careful thinking will be crucial. That's when Beckwith's Defending Life will be helpful indeed."
Ryan T. Anderson, National Review
"This is important work... Beckwith performs a most effective demolition job on the pro-choice movement's more hackneyed arguments... [This book] is worthwhile reading for pro-life thinkers who wish to track Roe's deadly march through the American intelligentsia. It's more worthwhile still for pro-life thinkers who know that, while Roe may have won many battles since 1973, the war is far from over. Defending Life will equip pro-life activists to make a logically sound defense of human dignity."
Douglas LeBlanc, Christianity Today
"Defending Life is a profound and vigorous defense of the right to life, as well as a comprehensive rebuttal to every conceivable argument in favor of abortion."
Inside The Vatican
"...Beckwith has written a careful and meticulous treatise about why the fetus should have a personhood status equal to that of a born human being from the moment of conception. This is exactly where legislation is heading, and his book may bolster those efforts..."
--Eileen McDonagh, Northeastern University
About the Author
Francis J. Beckwith is Associate Professor of Philosophy & Church-State Studies, Baylor University, where he teaches in the departments of philosophy and political science and the J. M. Dawson Institute of Church-State Studies. A 2002-2003 Madison Research Fellow in the Politics Department at Princeton University, he is a graduate of Fordham University (Ph.D., philosophy) and the Washington University School of Law, St. Louis (M.J.S.), where he won the CALI Award for academic excellence in the Reproductive Control Seminar. His more than a dozen books include Is Statecraft Soulcraft? Christianity and Politics (forthcoming); To Everyone an Answer: A Case for the Christian Worldview (2004); Law, Darwinism, and Public Education: The Establishment and the Challenge of Intelligent Design (2003); Do the Right Thing: Readings in Applied Ethics and Social Philosophy, Second Edition (2002); and The New Mormon Challenge: Responding to the Latest Defenses of a Fast-Growing Movement (2002), which was a finalist for the Gold Medallion Award in theology and doctrine. With interests in jurisprudence, politics, philosophy of religion, and public policy, Professor Beckwith has published in a wide variety of academic journals including the Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy, Journal of Social Philosophy, International Philosophical Quarterly, Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly, Journal of Medicine & Philosophy, American Journal of Jurisprudence, Journal of Medical Ethics, Public Affairs Quarterly, Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy, Social Theory & Practice, Southern Baptist Journal of Theology, Christian Bioethics, Nevada Law Journal, Journal of Law & Religion, and Philosophia Christi.
Most helpful customer reviews
55 of 62 people found the following review helpful.
The case against abortion
By Bill Muehlenberg
This is certainly the newest pro-life work to appear, and arguably among the best. It not only lays out the legal, rational, moral and philosophical case against abortion choice, but it more broadly makes the case for human equality and the sanctity of life.
Beckwith is an American professor of law and philosophy who has written extensively on these issues previously. This volume brings together years of thinking and debating on this contentious issue. It is an invaluable resource for all those wishing to stand up for human life at all stages of development, and to counter the arguments of the pro-choice brigade.
The first third of the book paints with broad brush strokes, examining moral reasoning, legal considerations, and political dimensions of the abortion debate.
The second third of the book looks more closely at the abortion debate per se, looking at the science, the morality and the arguments involved in the debate about abortion.
The final third of the book extends these considerations to recent developments in bioethics, including cloning and stem cell research.
The second and longest section of this book does many things, including carefully dismantling the various arguments put forward by the pro-abortion camp. All the leading pro-abortion thinkers, such as Thompson, Boonin, Stretton, and Dworkin are taken on, with their positions carefully assessed and interacted with.
On the broader issue of human equality, Beckwith argues for the substance view which states that a human being "is intrinsically valuable because of the sort of thing it is and the human being remains that sort of thing as long as it exists". That is, an individual "maintains absolute identity through time while it grows, develops, and undergoes numerous changes".
Various functions and capacities, whether fully realised or utilised do not constitute a person. Thus a human being is never a potential person, but is always a person at different stages of development, whether potential properties and capacities are actualised or not.
This view stand in stark contrast to the utilitarian and functionalist views held by most pro-abortionists. They argue that personhood is not inherent or intrinsic, but based on certain capacities and functions, be it consciousness, sentience, self-awareness, the ability to reason, and so on.
As to the specifics of the abortion debate, Beckwith responds to the numerous objections raised by pro-abortionists over the years. For example, consider the argument often heard, involving the hard cases of rape and incest. These are certainly tragic events, but in no way can they be used to justify an abortion.
First, such cases are extremely rare, making up just a tiny fraction of all abortions. Second, to argue for the legalisation of abortion because of these extreme cases would be similar to arguing that we eliminate traffic laws because in some rare cases they need to be violated, as in rushing a loved one to hospital.
Third, it simply begs the question by assuming the unborn child is not fully human. Fifth, to justify abortion in these circumstances is to argue that it is acceptable to forfeit a life for the alleged benefit of another. But a basic ethical intuition argues that we may not kill one person to possibly save another. John may desperately need a vital organ of Mary to stay alive, but he has no right to demand it, especially if it entails killing her in the process.
The more recent, and difficult, cases of embryo research, human cloning and stem cell therapies are also examined, looking at the various justifications given for them, and their pro-life responses. Similar issues arise here concerning the nature of personhood and the inviolability of life.
Beckwith closes by laying out his case as it has been argued throughout: the unborn are full members of the human community; it is wrong to kill members of that community; abortion kills the unborn entity; therefore abortion is morally wrong.
The three hundred pages of tightly-knit argumentation and logical-constructed reasoning take on nearly all the major justifications for abortion. All are found wanting - morally, legally, and philosophically. Beckwith is to be praised for assembling in one volume some of the best pro-life argumentation around.
47 of 53 people found the following review helpful.
Outstanding Contribution to Abortion Debate
By Scott Klusendorf
Beckwith's primary purpose is to provide a thorough defense of the pro-life position and its grounding in the "substance view" of human persons--a view he claims best explains human equality. He writes: "This book is, in a sense, then, not really a book about abortion, but rather, a book about human equality." Frank contends that the larger metaphysical question--who are we?--should be answered by enlarging our definition of the human family to include the unborn. His secondary purpose is to examine the relationship between abortion and law, politics, and public discourse.
The pro-life argument Frank defends can be outlined as follows:
1. The unborn entity, from the moment of conception, is a full-fledged member of the human community.
2. It is prima facie morally wrong to kill any member of that community.
3. Every successful abortion kills an unborn entity, a full-fledged member of the human community.
4. Therefore, every successful abortion is prima facie morally wrong.
The book is divided into three parts. Part 1 deals with moral reasoning, the law, and politics. Part 2 is the core of Frank's case for the pro-life view, which includes both the scientific and philosophic considerations. Part 3 takes on cloning and embryonic stem-cell research.
The thrust of the text is philosophical and jurisprudential rather than religious. In each case, the arguments presented pass the test of public reason. That's not because he thinks theology doesn't count as real knowledge (indeed, he argues elsewhere it does). Rather, he's cutting-off secular critics who unjustly dismiss pro-life arguments with the wand of "faith"--which they define as non-rational and subjective.
Frank sums up the current controversy this way: "At the end of the day, the abortion debate is about who and what we are and whether we can know it."
33 of 37 people found the following review helpful.
People are People no Matter How Small
By G. Passantino
Dr. Francis J. Beckwith's Defending Life is simply the best, most comprehensive, most logically sound examination of abortion & the meaning of personhood available in print today. Excellent summaries of the book are available elsewhere, so let me focus on some unique features.
First, Dr. Beckwith argues for a definition & moral value to humanity that provides a defense for innocent humans in a wide variety of circumstances, not just those who are tiny & preborn. The general philosophical arguments used here are helpful for evaluating human value among those in undeveloped, famine plagued regions of the world; among populations of hardened, committed career criminals; among those yet to be conceived several generations after our pollution-promoting public policies; & those who are physically and/or mentally disabled, etc.
Second, Dr. Beckwith treats abortion rights advocates with respect & honesty, not merely fairly representing their views & arguments, but even improving their arguments when he can & yet showing that even the best abortion rights arguments fatally undermine basic human rights based on the nature of humanity. A number of years ago, I role-played an abortion rights advocate in a public debate with Dr. Beckwith. He was concerned that his opponent be formidable & insightful, but he couldn't find an available true advocate he thought would do a credible enough job. I gave it my best shot (& Dr. Beckwith kindly said I was his toughest opponent to date), but Dr. Beckwith's arguments remained compelling & invincible. That generous respect & yet actual superiority is reflected in this book.
Third, Dr. Beckwith's sharp wit makes this book a serendipitous pleasure to read as well. Without demeaning his opponents or trivializing the issues, he is able to broach illustrations packed with humor & allude to cultural comedy to make telling points. As Dr. Beckwith's students will attest, he is nothing like the typical boring philosophy professor.
Fourth, this book provides such a wide spectrum of issues, arguments, & approaches that if you only have one book on the subject in your library, you should have this one -- even (or especially) if you are an abortion rights advocate.
Regardless of your familiarity with the subject or other volumes you might possess, you can't afford to miss getting & studying your own copy of Defending Life.
See all 9 customer reviews...
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith PDF
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith EPub
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith Doc
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith iBooks
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith rtf
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith Mobipocket
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith Kindle
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith PDF
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith PDF
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith PDF
Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice, by Francis J. Beckwith PDF
